Semaglutide vs. tirzepatide: one loses 12 lb more on average

Madison Shari researched both before her first injection and chose the one with bigger weight loss and lower side effects, even though it cost more.

Semaglutide vs Tirzepatide | Which is better?

Madison Shari sat down with the numbers before her first injection. Two drugs, both proven for weight loss, both expensive, both with side effects. One question: which one would get her to goal weight faster.

She had PCOS, cardiovascular disease and 30 or 40 lb she could not lose after her second baby. She did not want to be on a GLP-1 forever. She wanted short-term therapy, the fastest route to goal weight, and then off. So she looked at the trial data, the side effect rates, the cost with and without insurance, and the difference in results.

Five months later she hit her goal weight on tirzepatide and started a six-week wean. Here is what the research showed her, what she picked, and why she thinks she saved money by choosing the more expensive drug.

1. Tirzepatide patients lost 12 lb more on average

In a 68-week trial, patients on semaglutide lost an average of 15% of their body weight. A 200 lb patient lost about 30 lb.

In a 72-week trial, patients on tirzepatide lost an average of 21% of their body weight. A 200 lb patient lost about 42 lb.

That is a 12 lb difference. Both drugs work, Madison says, but tirzepatide is clearly better for weight loss.

Tirzepatide does clearly seem to lead to more weight loss but both semaglutide and tirzepatide seem to be excellent for weight loss. Tirzepatide is just a little better.Madison Shari

2. Side effects were lower across the board on tirzepatide

In the Wegovy trials, patients experienced nausea 44% of the time, diarrhea 30%, vomiting 24%, and constipation 24%.

In the Zepbound trials, patients experienced nausea 25 to 28% of the time, diarrhea 19 to 23%, vomiting 8 to 13%, and constipation 11 to 17%.

Madison points out that experiencing a side effect does not mean it was constant or severe. It might have been mild nausea one day of the week, or it might have been vomiting multiple days. The percentages do not tell you intensity.

Her own side effects on tirzepatide peaked between days two and four after her shot: a little extra tired, some nausea, some GI upset. She timed her injections for Wednesday or Thursday nights so the worst days hit over the weekend. She did not feel sick like the flu. She felt a little off.

Why this matters if you haven’t started yet: If you are deciding between the two, ask your provider about starting on whichever has the lower side effect profile for the symptom you are most worried about.

3. Name-brand tirzepatide is cheaper if insurance won't cover it

Wegovy lists at $1,350 for a 28-day supply with no insurance or coupons. Its savings card can take $250 off if your commercial insurance will not cover it.

Zepbound lists at $1,060 for a one-month supply. Its savings card can bring the cost down to $550 if your commercial insurance will not cover it.

Very few insurances cover either drug anymore, Madison says. If yours does, you won the lottery. Some may cover Wegovy if you have cardiovascular disease, since it is now FDA approved for that condition, or because it has been around longer.

Compounded semaglutide runs about $129 a month through her telehealth provider. Compounded tirzepatide is $179 a month, though the price increases with dose. Still cheaper than name brand, she says, but an investment.

4. She chose tirzepatide because five months beats eight

Madison went with compounded tirzepatide at $179 a month. Better weight loss, lower side effects, and her plan was never to stay on long term.

If tirzepatide got her to goal weight in five months and semaglutide would have taken eight, she saved money on tirzepatide. Fewer months at a higher per-month price still costs less total.

She also wanted the cardiovascular benefits. Research is ongoing, she says, but it looks fabulous. And she had cardiovascular disease going in.

Why this matters if you haven’t started yet: If your goal is short-term therapy to a specific weight, do the math on total cost, not monthly cost.

5. She lost 6 or 7 lb in the first week

Week one on tirzepatide, Madison dropped 6 or 7 lb. She says that is not totally normal but common in the first week when you lose a lot of water weight and inflammation drops.

She had been carrying hormonal water weight from PCOS. Her cheekbones came back. The puffiness was gone. Even after one week she noticed a big difference.

From then on she lost one or two pounds a week. Every once in a while she had a three-pound week. She focused on strength training, regular exercise, high protein, low carb, lots of fiber, and sleep.

She hit goal weight at the end of month four. Now she is doing a six-week wean at half her starting dose and has not gained any back.

6. What helped with side effects: timing, naps, electrolytes, food

Madison timed her shots for Wednesday or Thursday night so peak side effects hit over the weekend when she could rest. She has two little kids, so resting was not always possible, but it helped.

Taking a nap if she could, drinking an electrolyte drink, making sure she was eating and eating well. None of it made the side effects disappear, but it made them manageable.

Why this matters if you haven’t started yet: Side effects on tirzepatide usually peak days two through four after your injection. Plan your week around that.

7. She went compounded and it was easier than she expected

Her insurance does not cover GLP-1s. She did not want to pay $550 a month for name-brand Zepbound. So she uses compounded tirzepatide through a telehealth provider, Join Friday.

The medicine comes in a vial. You draw it out with an insulin needle and self-inject. She was nervous at first because she has no clinical background, but it has been totally fine. Not hard to figure out.

The medicine works, it comes sterile, and Join Friday only uses licensed pharmacies and medical-grade compounding medication. She feels good about it.

8. You can switch between the two if you need to

If you are on tirzepatide and having a lot of side effects, you can switch to semaglutide to see if your body responds better. If you are on semaglutide and hit a weight loss plateau, you can switch to tirzepatide.

Your provider will have a plan. If you are switching from semaglutide to tirzepatide, they might start you on the starting dose of tirzepatide or a mid dose since you were already on a GLP-1. It depends on the provider.

Either way, it is something you can do. You are not locked in.

9. The food noise came back during the wean

Madison is now in her fifth month, doing a long wean at half her starting dose. The food noise is back. It is uncomfortable, and she is learning coping strategies.

That is the one bummer about coming off, she says. But her body feels amazingly healthier. She does not feel exhausted all the time. She is continuing her lifestyle changes and has no regrets.

I'm so glad I did this. No regrets.Madison Shari

Notice what decided it for her: not the drug name, not the pen, not the brand loyalty. It was five months versus eight, $900 total versus $1,400 total, and whether she would get to goal weight fast enough to get off before the food noise came back.

She did. The research on getting off these drugs is mostly in people with chronic obesity or diabetes, and most of them regain the weight. But Madison thinks her situation is different. She was situationally overweight, hormonally out of balance, postpartum and stuck. Five months later her body feels stronger, her cheekbones are back, and the exhaustion is gone. The food noise is uncomfortable, but she is learning to live with it again. Two years from now, the studies may tell us more about people like her. Right now, she is just glad she picked the one that got her there faster.

Questions people ask

How much more weight do people lose on tirzepatide versus semaglutide?

In trials, tirzepatide patients lost an average of 21% of body weight over 72 weeks versus 15% on semaglutide over 68 weeks. For a 200 lb person, that is about 42 lb on tirzepatide versus 30 lb on semaglutide, a 12 lb difference.

Are side effects worse on semaglutide or tirzepatide?

Tirzepatide had lower side effect rates across the board in trials. Nausea was 25 to 28% on tirzepatide versus 44% on semaglutide. Vomiting was 8 to 13% versus 24%. Diarrhea and constipation were also lower on tirzepatide.

Can you switch from semaglutide to tirzepatide or vice versa?

Yes. Your provider will have a plan for switching, either starting you on the initial dose of the new drug or a mid dose depending on what you were taking before. You can switch if side effects are too much or if weight loss has stalled.

MS
Madison Shari

Madison Shari is a GLP-1 user who started tirzepatide five months ago after having her second baby and struggling with PCOS, cardiovascular disease and hormonal weight gain. 38,431 views on the original video.

Watch the original on YouTube →

Trending Topics

Free, from GLP‑1 Classified

Thinking about a GLP‑1? Read our guide before you start.

The questions to ask, the costs nobody mentions, and what the first month really feels like. Plus a short weekly letter for people on, or considering, a GLP‑1. We are not a pharmacy or a telehealth brand. We work for you, not for them.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.